Russia: Government Shuts
HIV-Prevention Group's Website
Move is an Assault on Freedom of Expression
February 8, 2012 - (Moscow) - The Russian government's anti-drugs agency has ordered the blocking of
the website of a public health organization, the Andrey Rylkov Foundation, for discussing the addiction medicine methadone, human
rights groups said today. The move is an assault on freedom of expression in the midst of pro-democracy protests, the groups said.
The order from the Federal Drug Control Service (FSKN) Moscow Department went into effect on February 3, 2012. The order
claims the move is due to the "placement of materials that propagandize (advertise) the use of drugs, information about distribution,
purchasing of drugs and inciting the use of drugs."
Methadone, which the World Health Organization classifies as an essential medicine for the treatment of opiate dependence,
is illegal in Russia.
The website is maintained by the Andrey Rylkov Foundation, which advocates health-based drug policies and has been a vocal
critic of the Russian government's ban on methadone. The website included international research findings on methadone showing that this
treatment reduces HIV risk among users of heroin and other opiates and also helps people stay on AIDS and TB treatments. An English
version of the website is online at www.rylkov-fond.org .
"People all over the world take this medication for granted, but here in Russia it's central to our struggle against HIV
and it's banned," said Anya Sarang, president of the foundation. "Now, even our speaking about it seems to be banned."
International health and human rights groups including ARTICLE 19, Human Rights Watch, Harm Reduction International, the
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, and the International Centre for Science in Drug Policy, criticized the government's decision.
"The government has nothing to gain by censoring this small organization for trying to help people stay safe,"
said Diederik Lohman , senior health researcher at
Human Rights Watch. "It is totally unacceptable and evidence of the Russian authorities' ongoing resistance to
internationally accepted methods of HIV prevention and international standards for freedom of expression."
Russia has one of the largest populations of injecting drug users in the world, as well as one of the fastest growing HIV
epidemics. An estimated 980,000 people are living with HIV in Russia. In some regions, as many as 80 percent of those with HIV contracted
the virus through contaminated injection equipment.
"The right to information is essential to realizing the right to health," said Agnes Callamard, executive director of
ARTICLE 19. "State authorities should respectthe right to health and refrain from restricting access to health-related information or
withholding or intentionally misrepresenting health-related information. A government agency such as Federal Drug Control Service
should not have the ability to ban websites at the whim of a bureaucrat. This is particularly so when considering the impact of
censoring discussions relating to drug addiction or HIV/AIDS."
The Russian government refuses to allow methadone treatment, despite dozens of studies from around the world showing the
medicine to be effective in HIV prevention and treatment. Instead, Russian officials recommend "narcology", an abstinence-based system
designed to treat alcoholics and largely ineffective or harmful for those dependent on opiates.
"In Russia, with so many people contracting HIV through injecting with unsterile equipment, and with thousands of overdose
deaths each year, accurate and objective health information among people who inject drugs is a matter of life and death," Said Dr. Evan Wood
of the International Center for Science in Drug Policy.
In 2006, the Russian government forced the closure of another website, by the prominent physician Vladimir Mendelevich,
which contained information about methadone.
Human rights and health advocates contend that Russia's failure to allow information or services helpful to drug users
breaches international human rights law and public health norms.
"Russia has a duty to respect, protect and promote access to health care, including for effective drug treatment and HIV
prevention" said Rick Lines, executive director of Harm Reduction International. "Instead, they are slamming the door on basic health
information and sending the message to millions of citizens that their lives are not worth saving."